InsightsRajasthan RERA
Rajasthan RERA / REUNION INSIGHTS

Rajasthan RERA recognizes delay claim based on possession commitments in email

In Complaint No. RAJ-RERA-C-2018-2618, Rajasthan RERA accepted that email possession commitments could be relevant despite a later contractual timeline and granted delay-related relief on the buyer...

Rajasthan RERA recognizes delay claim based on possession commitments in emailREUNION / INSIGHTSCLARITY / CONTEXT / PERSPECTIVE
Reunion Insights editorial image

In this article, we delve into the intriguing case involving the Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) and a dispute involving the developer. The case revolves around the non-delivery of possession of the property and Complainant A's demand for compensation.

The jurisdiction of this case falls under the Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority in Jaipur, and it is governed by the RERA Act of 2016. Let's explore the background and key details of this case to gain a deeper understanding.

Background of the Case

The case concerns a real-estate project in Jodhpur. The developer entered into an agreement for sale, where Complainant A deposited Rs. 1.00 lac as a booking amount on 30.12.2016. The agreement lacked a specific date but mentioned an estimated possession date of five years from the agreement date, i.e., 21.02.2023, with a grace period of one year.

The project's registration was done in phases, with Phase I, II, and III registered in 2017. Each phase reported a finish date before the authority, and the final deadline for completion was set for 31.07.2023. The agreement's Schedule 7 specified that Complainant A had deposited Rs. 13.00 lacs by 10.02.2017 against the total consideration of Rs. 36,63,300/-.

Dispute and Claim

Complainant A claimed that the promoter's representatives assured him of possession by December 2017, later extended to March 2018 through email correspondence. When the possession was not delivered as promised, Complainant A sought the following relief:

  • Monthly compensation of Rs. 32,000/- from December 2017 until possession is received.
  • Compensation for mental harassment amounting to Rs. 1,00,000/-
  • Litigation charges of Rs. 50,000/-

The emails exchanged between Complainant A and the promoter's representatives proved the commitment made for possession. While the agreement's tenure indicated a later date, the emails contradicted these terms.

Arguments by the Respondent

The respondent claimed that the complaint was premature as the agreement's tenure ended on 14.02.2023. They argued that RERA registration was subsequent to the agreement and didn't affect its terms. The respondent also addressed the issue of loan disbursement, stating there was no information on the amount paid through the loan facility.

RERA Authority's Decision

The RERA Authority examined the case thoroughly, considering evidence and correspondence. They found that the promoter's representatives had indeed promised possession by December 2017 and later by March 2018, making the complaint valid.

The authority clarified that the project's ongoing status falls under RERA's ambit, rejecting the claim of pre-mature complaint. Consequently, the authority ordered the promoter to compensate Complainant A, including interest against the deposited amount.

Implications and Takeaways

This case holds significant implications for both real estate buyers and promoters. It emphasizes the need for adherence to commitments and transparent communication in property transactions. RERA's role in resolving disputes and safeguarding consumer rights gains prominence.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Rajasthan RERA case sheds light on the importance of fulfilling commitments made during property sales. Despite the agreement's tenure, the authority recognized the validity of Complainant A's complaint based on email evidence. This decision reinforces the accountability of promoters in delivering possession as promised.

Aspiring property buyers and promoters alike should take this case as a cautionary tale, valuing transparency and adherence to RERA guidelines. The real estate market can thrive when trust is established between all stakeholders. Let's strive for a fair and transparent real estate industry under RERA's purview.

R
Reunion Insights

Research, explainers and perspectives.

CONTINUE READING

More from Reunion Insights