In the world of real estate, proper regulation and compliance play a crucial role in ensuring the rights and protection of buyers. One such case that has caught the attention of the Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) is the dispute between Complainant A, the complainant, and the developer, the respondent, regarding the project. The project, located in Tijara, Alwar, is mired in controversy as it remains unregistered and incomplete.
The complainant claims that despite entering into a Buyers Agreement with the respondent on 14.10.2015, the possession of the booked unit has not been delivered as per the expected timeline. Seeking justice, the complainant demands a refund of Rs. 15,78,888/- along with an interest rate of 24% per annum against the total consideration of Rs. 17.20 lac. Let us delve deeper into the case to understand the intricacies involved.
Background
The Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) was established with the aim of regulating the real estate sector and safeguarding the interests of buyers. One of the key requirements under RERA is the mandatory registration of real estate projects. This ensures transparency and accountability from developers, protecting buyers from potential fraudulent practices.
In this context, the project, undertaken by the developer, has come under the scrutiny of RERA. The project's non-registration raises concerns about compliance with legal requirements and the rights of the homebuyers. The registration process, coupled with obtaining a valid completion certificate, is pivotal in determining the project's legitimacy and completion status.
Complaint Details
Complainant A, the complainant, approached the Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) under Section 31 of the Act, highlighting the unregistered status of the booked unit in the project. The complainant asserts that the project, despite being ongoing, has not been registered as mandated by RERA. Additionally, the complainant refers to the Buyers Agreement executed on 14.10.2015, which stated an expected delivery timeline of 36 months from the agreement date. According to this timeline, the possession of the unit was expected by 14.10.2018.
However, the respondent, the developer, failed to deliver the possession within the stipulated period, prompting the complainant to seek a refund of Rs. 15,78,888/- along with interest at a rate of 24% per annum. The complainant contends that the ongoing project falls within the purview of the retroactive application of the RERA provisions, entitling them to the claimed refund.
Respondent's Arguments
In response to the complaint, the respondent filed a reply, presenting their side of the story. The respondent argues that force majeure should be considered as an applicable factor, as unforeseen circumstances hindered the completion of the project within the agreed timeline. Furthermore, the respondent claims that the project is not incomplete and submits photographs as evidence to support this assertion.
Authority's Assessment
The Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) carefully assessed the arguments put forth by both parties and examined the records to arrive at a fair judgment. The Authority refers to its previous direction in a similar case involving non-registration of a project, wherein it was established that the project required registration. The respondent's contention that the project was already reported as complete to the developer Authority (BIDA) on 25.04.2017 was deemed unsubstantiated, as the relevant document was not provided to the Authority.
Based on these considerations, the Authority maintains its stance that the project remains incomplete until a valid completion certificate, issued by the competent authority and aligned with the sanctioned layout plan, is presented.
Partial Completion Certificate
During the proceedings, the respondent presented a partly completion certificate dated 14.05.2019 as evidence. However, it is important to note that this certificate only pertains to Block "A" and Block "D" of the project, excluding the complainant's Block "B". Consequently, this certificate cannot be applied to validate the completion of the complainant's unit.
Precedents and Refund Request
To support the refund claim, the complainant's advocate relied on earlier Authority decisions favouring buyers, including a Full Bench decision dated 14.06.2019.
Authority's Decision and Order
After careful consideration of the facts and arguments presented, the Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) delivers its decision. The complaint filed by Complainant A is upheld, and the respondent, the developer, is directed to refund the deposited amount of Rs. 15,78,888/- along with interest.
The interest rate is calculated at 8.6%, comprising the highest Marginal Cost of Lending Rate (MCLR) of the State Bank of India (SBI) plus 2%. The interest is applicable from 14.10.2018, excluding any moratorium period notified by the Authority. The respondent is given a period of 45 days from the date of the order's upload on the Authority's website to comply with the refund directive.
Non-Compliance Consequences
In the event of non-compliance within the specified period, the Authority directs the Registry to initiate recovery proceedings under Section 40 of the Act. If the complainant files an application for execution within two years from the issuance of the order, the case will be transmitted to the concerned District Collector for further action.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the case of the unregistered and incomplete the project sheds light on the significance of proper registration and compliance with the Rajasthan Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) guidelines. The Authority's decision in favor of the complainant reaffirms the commitment to safeguarding the rights of buyers and upholding transparency in the real estate sector. This case serves as a reminder to all developers and promoters to adhere to the regulations set forth by RERA, ensuring timely completion and delivery of projects, thereby fostering trust and confidence among homebuyers.


