In a significant development, the Karnataka Real Estate Appellate Tribunal has delivered a judgment upholding the delay compensation order against promoter the developer. The case, with reference number FR No. (K-REAT) 53/2023, revolves around a real estate project called "the project." The tribunal's decision comes as a setback for the promoter, as it validates the claims made by allottees Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B regarding project delays and non-delivery of possession. This in-depth article delves into the details of the case and the implications of the tribunal's ruling.
Background of the Case
The dispute stems from an agreement of sale signed on April 16, 2015, between the developer and allottees Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B. The agreement pertained to the booked unit in a residential block of the project, located in Bangalore. As per the agreement, the promoter was obligated to complete the project and deliver possession of the flat by April 16, 2017, including a grace period of six months.
Allegations and Complaint
Alleging a breach of the agreement by the promoter, the allottees filed a complaint before the Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority (K-RERA). The complaint, bearing number CMP/200130/0004909, sought delay compensation due to the failure of timely project completion and possession. The complainants argued that the developer had not fulfilled their obligations as agreed upon, leading to financial and emotional distress.
Authority's Order
After considering the complaint, objections from the promoter, and hearing both parties, the K-RERA passed an order on December 29, 2022. The order acknowledged the complainants' claims and held the promoter liable for delay compensation. It directed the developer to pay interest on the delay period amounting to Rs. 50,11,552 calculated at the rate of 9% per annum from April 16, 2017, to April 30, 2017. Furthermore, interest was to be paid at the rate of SBI MCLR + 2% from May 1, 2017, to November 21, 2019.
Promoter's Appeal and Non-Compliance
Displeased with the K-RERA's decision, the developer filed an appeal before the Karnataka Real Estate Appellate Tribunal under Section 44 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. The appeal aimed to set aside the order passed by the K-RERA.
However, the promoter failed to comply with office objections raised by the tribunal. Specifically, the requirement to deposit the total amount payable to the allottees as per the impugned order, as mandated under the proviso to Section 43(5) of the Act, was not fulfilled. Despite granting sufficient opportunities to comply, the appellant did not meet the prescribed obligations.
Tribunal's Judgment
Taking into account the non-compliance of office objections, including the failure to deposit the necessary amount, the Karnataka Real Estate Appellate Tribunal dismissed the promoter's appeal. The tribunal referred to the proviso to sub-Section (5) of Section 43 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, which mandates the pre-deposit of a statutory amount by the appellant.
Citing the Supreme Court's decision interpreting the Section 43(5) pre-deposit requirement, the tribunal emphasized that the pre-deposit requirement is not onerous or in violation of constitutional rights. Consequently, the dismissal of the appeal led to the rejection of any pending interim applications associated with the case.
Implications and Conclusion
The Appellate Tribunal's decision to uphold the delay compensation order against the developer carries significant implications. It affirms the rights of the allottees and reinforces the importance of timely project completion and delivery in the real estate sector. The judgment sets a precedent for promoting accountability among promoters and ensuring that homebuyers receive due compensation for project delays.
In conclusion, the case of the developer vs. Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B serves as a reminder of the legal recourse available to homebuyers facing project delays. The tribunal's ruling highlights the need for promoters to adhere to their contractual obligations, protecting the interests of allottees and maintaining the integrity of the real estate industry.


