InsightsHaryana RERA
Haryana RERA / REUNION INSIGHTS

Haryana RERA appeal remanded after relevant precedent was not considered

The appellate tribunal set aside a dismissal and sent the matter back for a fresh decision after finding that relevant legal precedent had not been considered.

Haryana RERA appeal remanded after relevant precedent was not consideredREUNION / INSIGHTSCLARITY / CONTEXT / PERSPECTIVE
Reunion Insights editorial image

A Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal appeal challenged an Authority order dated 27 April 2022 in Complaint No. 377 of 2021 concerning delayed-possession interest.

Authority's original reasoning

The Authority had dismissed the complaint after noting that possession had already been taken and conveyance deeds had been executed on 8 April 2019. It treated the conveyance as bringing the contractual relationship to an end and also noted that the complaint had been filed substantially later.

Ground of appeal

The appellant argued that the Authority had not considered relevant Supreme Court and Haryana appellate precedent dealing with delayed-possession rights after possession or conveyance.

The appeal therefore focused not only on the underlying interest claim but on whether the first-instance decision had applied the relevant legal principles.

Appellate Tribunal's decision

In Appeal No. 701 of 2022, the Appellate Tribunal found merit in the contention that relevant precedent had not been considered.

It set aside the order and remanded the matter to the Authority for a fresh decision after taking the applicable judgments into account.

Practical significance

The ruling is a procedural reminder that a conveyance deed or completed possession does not automatically answer every delayed-possession claim without reference to the governing law and precedent.

It also illustrates the appellate function of correcting a decision-making process when a material legal authority has been overlooked, without necessarily deciding the underlying claim itself.

R
Reunion Insights

Research, explainers and perspectives.

CONTINUE READING

More from Reunion Insights