InsightsHaryana RERA
Haryana RERA / REUNION INSIGHTS

Haryana appellate tribunal remands villa-possession dispute after NCLT proceeding ends

In Appeal No. 110 of 2021, the Haryana appellate tribunal set aside an earlier disposal based on a parallel NCLT proceeding and remitted the villa-possession complaint to Haryana RERA after that pr...

Haryana appellate tribunal remands villa-possession dispute after NCLT proceeding endsREUNION / INSIGHTSCLARITY / CONTEXT / PERSPECTIVE
Reunion Insights editorial image

In a significant real estate dispute, the developer has filed a complaint against Party A and Respondent B. The case revolves around the non-possession of a villa, allegations of substandard construction, and a breach of agreement. The Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal has played a crucial role in resolving this matter. This article provides an in-depth analysis of the case, including the background, arguments presented, and the tribunal's decision.

Background

  • Appellant: the developer
  • Appellant's Representative: the developer's representative
  • Respondent 1: Party A
  • Respondent 2: Respondent B

Complaint and Disposal:

  • Complaint No.: CR/5006/2019 filed by the developer against Party A and Respondent B.
  • Complaint Disposal Date: 12.02.2021 by the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority.
  • Disposal Decision: The complaint was disposed of, advising the developer to pursue the matter before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) due to its pending status there.

Case Details

Property Allotment and Agreement:

The developer allotted a villa (the booked villa) measuring 267 square yards with a super built-up area of 5605 sq. ft. to Party A and Respondent B. This villa was part of the project located at Sector 65/66, Gurugram, Haryana. The parties executed a Buyer's Agreement on 05.03.2014, which specified a possession period of 30 months, with a grace period of three months from the commencement of development work.

Allegations by the developer:

The developer claimed that it offered possession of the villa to Party A and Respondent B on 06.06.2019 after they paid the outstanding amount of Rs.3,20,47,909/-. However, the respondents did not accept the offer, leading the developer to file a complaint seeking possession of the villa and the outstanding payments.

Counterarguments by Party A and Respondent B:

Party A and Respondent B countered the developer's claims by stating that the villa offered was substandard and unfit for habitation. They argued that the actual construction significantly deviated from the luxurious villa advertised. The respondents also highlighted issues such as inadequate infrastructure and lack of proper access to the villa. They terminated the agreement on 02.09.2019, prior to the filing of the complaint by the developer.

Tribunal's Decision

Initial Disposal:

On 12.02.2021, the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority disposed of the complaint by advising the developer to pursue the matter before the NCLT, as it was already pending there. The complaint was set aside, and the file was consigned to the registry.

Appeal and NCLT Dismissal:

The developer appealed the disposal order and highlighted the subsequent dismissal of Party A and Respondent B's petition under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, by the NCLT. The NCLT dismissed the respondents' petition as withdrawn on 26.09.2022.

Tribunal's Verdict:

The Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal allowed the developer's appeal, setting aside the disposal order and remitting the complaint back to the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority for a fresh trial and decision. The authority was instructed to expedite the process and scheduled a hearing for 03.02.2023.

Conclusion

The real estate dispute between the developer and Party A and Respondent B showcases the complexities and challenges faced in the industry. With the case now remitted back to the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority for further proceedings, it remains to be seen how the matter will be resolved. This case highlights the importance of addressing construction quality concerns and adhering to contractual obligations to maintain trust and transparency in the real estate sector.

R
Reunion Insights

Research, explainers and perspectives.

CONTINUE READING

More from Reunion Insights