InsightsHaryana RERA
Haryana RERA / REUNION INSIGHTS

Haryana appellate tribunal disposes appeal over project fund monitoring and regulatory findings

In Appeal No. 496 of 2021, the Haryana appellate tribunal reviewed challenges to RERA observations on alleged fund diversion, pricing, audit findings and project monitoring, while leaving any indep...

Haryana appellate tribunal disposes appeal over project fund monitoring and regulatory findingsREUNION / INSIGHTSCLARITY / CONTEXT / PERSPECTIVE
Reunion Insights editorial image

In a recent case before the Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, the apartment-buyer association filed an appeal against an order issued by the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority. The case involved multiple parties, including the developer. This article provides an in-depth analysis of the case, highlighting the key arguments, decisions, and implications.

Case Background:

Case Number: Appeal No. 496 of 2021

Date of Decision: 02.03.2023

The appellant was an apartment-buyer association. The respondents were two private developer entities.

Case Analysis:

The case was presided over by the Tribunal Chairperson as the Chairman of the Tribunal, with Tribunal Member A serving as the Member (Judicial) and Tribunal Member B as the Member (Technical). The respective advocates representing the parties were the appellant's counsel for the appellant, counsel for Respondent 1 for respondent no. 1, and counsel for Respondent 2 for respondent no. 2.

The appellant challenged the order passed by the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority on 07.09.2021. The Authority's order contained several conclusions, which were contested by the appellant in their appeal. The key points of contention were as follows:

  1. Diversion of Funds: The appellant alleged a suspected diversion of funds by the respondent companies. However, the respondents provided a satisfactory explanation through their counsel, counsel for Respondent 1. The Authority, after considering the funds invested and collected, concluded that there was no diversion of funds from the allottees of the project.
  2. Sample Agreements and Differential Pricing: The Authority directed the respondents to submit sample agreements of each type of villa to determine the justification for differential pricing. The respondents were given a timeframe of 10 days to submit the sample agreements to the Authority and the opposite party.
  3. Progress of the Project: The Authority expressed initial suspicion regarding the diversion of funds but acknowledged the progress shown by the promoters. The Authority decided to review its suspicion, considering that the first phase of the project was likely to be completed soon. The report of the auditor, which raised concerns based on incorrect assumptions, influenced the Authority's decision.
  4. Forensic Audit and Monitoring of Project Progress: To ensure transparency, the Authority had earlier ordered a forensic audit of the promoter's investments in the last year. The forensic audit report was submitted, and the respondents were directed to deposit the auditor's fee with the Authority. Additionally, the Authority decided to monitor the project's progress on a bi-monthly basis and requested the respondents to report the funds received and invested in the project, as well as the physical progress achieved.
  5. Refund of Money: The appellant's counsel raised a matter regarding a complainant in Complaint No.315 of 2018, who insisted on a refund of the money paid. The Authority decided not to hear this matter temporarily, awaiting the orders of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India concerning the Authority's jurisdiction for complaints involving fund-related relief.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, the apartment-buyer association's appeal against the order of the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority was heard and disposed of by the Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal, chaired by the Tribunal Chairperson, reviewed the appellant's contentions and clarified that the observations made in the Authority's order were solely for the purpose of deciding the matter before it. The Tribunal affirmed that the investigating agency would proceed independently and in accordance with the law.

This case highlights the importance of addressing suspicions of fund diversion and ensuring project completion and transparency in real estate developments. It also underscores the role of regulatory authorities and appellate tribunals in resolving disputes and safeguarding the interests of buyers and promoters in the real estate sector.

R
Reunion Insights

Research, explainers and perspectives.

CONTINUE READING

More from Reunion Insights