In a recent case heard before the Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, appeals were filed by the developer, a real estate company, against two allottees, Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B. The appeals arose from a decision made by the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Panchkula, in response to complaints filed by Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B seeking a refund of their deposited amount due to the developer's failure to fulfill the terms of their agreement. The key issue in this case was whether the authority had jurisdiction over the complaints as the project in question was an unregistered project.
Background:
Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B approached the authority seeking a refund of their deposited amount as the developer had allegedly not complied with the terms of the agreement for the allotted units. the developer argued that the authority did not have jurisdiction over complaints related to unregistered projects, citing a Supreme Court judgment. However, the authority rejected this argument and asserted its jurisdiction.
The Appeals:
Feeling aggrieved, the developer filed appeals against the authority's decision. The company claimed that its project was fully completed before the implementation of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, and therefore, the authority did not have jurisdiction over the complaints. the developer argued that the Act applied to ongoing and future projects only after their registration, and since their project was unregistered, it fell outside the purview of the Act.
Counterargument by Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B:
Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B's counsel countered the developer's argument, stating that the Act applied to unregistered projects as well. They cited a Supreme Court judgment, which held that the Act's provisions could be retroactively applied to ongoing projects that had not received a completion certificate.
Tribunal's Decision:
The tribunal carefully considered the arguments presented by both the developer and Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B. It examined the Supreme Court judgment and noted that the Act was intended to regulate both ongoing and future projects, including unregistered projects. The tribunal emphasized that the Act's application was retroactive in nature, meaning it could cover ongoing projects that had not yet obtained a completion certificate.
In this case, the developer failed to provide evidence that they had completed their project or obtained a completion certificate before the Act came into effect. The tribunal concluded that the authority had jurisdiction to adjudicate the dispute between the developer and Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B.
Conclusion:
Ultimately, the Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal dismissed the appeals filed by the developer, affirming the authority's jurisdiction over the complaints filed by Homebuyer A and Homebuyer B. The tribunal's decision clarified that the Act applied to ongoing and unregistered projects, providing protection to both allottees and promoters. This case serves as a precedent, ensuring that unscrupulous promoters cannot evade the Act's provisions by keeping their projects unregistered. The judgment upholds the interests of homebuyers and promotes transparency and accountability in the real estate sector.


